• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Gallery Pastry Shop

Gallery Pastry Shop, located in Indianapolis, is a trendy spot offering New American cuisine, cocktail bars, and brunch options. This woman-owned establishment caters to a diverse crowd with vegan and vegetarian choices, as well as plastic-free packaging and gender-neutral restrooms. The ambiance is described as hipster, casual, and modern, with unique seating arrangements and a striking tree centerpiece. Customers praise the food quality, especially dishes like croissant and gravy with scrambled eggs, lemon pappardelle pasta, and sweet crepes. The service may vary, but the overall experience seems to be delightful, making it a must-visit for brunch or a special outing.

LOCATIONS
  • Gallery Pastry Shop
    4573 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205
    4573 N College Ave Indianapolis, IN 46205 Hotline: (317) 820-5526

Welcome to Gallery Pastry Shop, a culinary gem nestled in the heart of Indianapolis at 4573 N College Ave. This inviting locale offers a fresh take on New American cuisine, merging the best of breakfast, brunch, and cocktail experiences all in one stylish space. The atmosphere is captivating, with a unique mix of seating and a stunning central tree, creating a vibrant yet cozy environment perfect for any gathering.

Gallery Pastry Shop is not just about the food; it’s about the entire experience. As one customer aptly put it, the “vibes” are a significant part of the dining adventure. Whether you're savoring a refreshing Delta Cucumber Mint Watermelon or indulging in the hearty Caesar Salad, every dish is crafted with care and imagination. For brunch enthusiasts, the standout is definitely the biscuit and gravy – reimagined as a flaky croissant paired with savory gravy and scrambled eggs. Reviews speak highly of this dish, highlighting not just its heartiness but also its balanced flavor profile, appealing to those who enjoy a mix of seasoning that is just right.

Gallery Pastry Shop excels in providing a delightful selection of beverages to accompany your meal. From the refreshing Delta Huckleberry Lemonade to locally sourced Circle Kombucha, there's something for everyone. Diners rave about the warm, inviting service, which enhances the overall dining experience, despite the occasional hiccup in timing during busy hours.

For those seeking an outdoor dining experience, the patio is perfect for enjoying warm evenings with friends or a loved one, while sipping on crafted cocktails. As one patron noted, the new menu items are exciting, prompting anticipation for future visits. Whether you’re in the mood for the lemon pappardelle pasta or the intriguing Brussels sprout & herb whipped cheese, every dish tells a story of creativity and passion.

If you’re looking for a spot that combines excellent food, charming decor, and a vibrant atmosphere, look no further than Gallery Pastry Shop. Brunch or dinner, this destination promises to deliver an unforgettable culinary experience that is both satisfying and unique.

START YOUR REVIEW OF Gallery Pastry Shop
Sean V.
Sean V.

Food and atmosphere were great‼ The waiter was nice and friendly. This is a brunch type of restaurant so breakfast is served all day . They serve beverages as well. I had the biscuit and gravy, but this was served different. It was a croissant and gravy with scrambled eggs. It will get you full and the taste wasn't too bland but also not allot of seasoning, just in the middle. I also had a screwdriver. Excellent

MaryBeth M.
MaryBeth M.

Food was excellent and tasty. Service was okay. We did have a big group. Appetizers were delivered after our meals. They did deliver a nice Birthday board of sweets for the 2 birthdays we were celebrating!!

Laura P.
Laura P.

So I had never been here before but had heard SO many good things about it. I love the type of seating and that everything is a little mismatched. I also love the giant tree in the middle. Makes it feel very modern. I had an egg sandwich and we split little donuts as an appetizer (they might call them beignets... I forget). I also had a vanilla latte. I will say that I feel like it was overpriced, even for broad ripple. I think that you pay for the vibes at this place. They do have great indoor seating and also a lot of outdoor seating. They have plenty of parking as well which is a plus.

Bryant W.
Bryant W.

Excellent products. Good service. Recommend for brunch and dinner and special offerings.

Eli S.
Eli S.

The outdoor patio was perfect for dinner & drinks! The new menu is great and I'm excited to try everything! Highly recommend the lemon pappardelle pasta and the Brussels sprout & herb whipped cheese.

Joanne Y.
Joanne Y.

Have heard good things about Gallery Pastry and finally decided to stop by. I made a bad choice to come at lunch time on a Sunday (haha). We didn't have a reservation so we did expect a long wait. The host/manager(?) kept updating us of when our table would be ready. There was a table that checked out but didn't leave for a long time so we ended up sitting at the bar area. It wasn't necessary, but we got a complimentary goodies for waiting long - the host obviously didn't expect the table to not clear out after checking out. We sat down and were warned that the food would take a long time - and it did take a long time. But overall, I would definitely come back - probably when it's not too busy. The 4 stars is for the great service we received from the front host/manager and server. We ordered the sticky black garlic wings, shrimp and grits, steak and egg, smash burger, and brunch carbonara. 1. Sticky Black Garlic Wings - it was good, but our's didn't come with the bok choy and ginger slaw (though the menu said it will), but we didn't care to bring it up since we were ready to just eat. 2. Shrimp and Grits - very yummy! 3. Steak and Egg - my sister said the steak was a little lukewarm, but it was not bad overall. 4. Smash Burger - was also lukewarm, but I thought the fries were good. 5. Brunch Carbonara - review pictures online showed spaghetti noodles, which my husband was expecting, but came with fettuccine noodles. Perhaps they rotate the noodles, but he didn't enjoy it as much as he would have loved to. We also had coffee from the front counter area while waiting to be seated. I had the latte that had the pear lavender and it was delicious! Will visit again soon to try other dishes!

Priscilla M.
Priscilla M.

Went for Mother's day on the Sat this year and this was my 3rd time going here!! This is personally one of my favorite brunch place as its got enough of savory and sweets - mainly sweets. This is a place to get mousse !! Might be the only place to get mousse. We ordered sweet crepe to share. I had savory crepe (vegan) - im not vegan but this is so delicious!! My husband ordered chicken and waffle (recommended) Staffs are all nice and friendly, its chilled too. When i called in to reserve a table , it was easy. The place is so chic, i love the many plants decor there - beautiful! 2nd time, i went w/ my friends to share a lot of the brunch menu! We sat outside. 1st time i went was still in 54th st location i believe but still left me a good memory! Love to see this grow!

Arjun K.
Arjun K.

Solid food and good ambiance. We got two appetizers. The Fried green tomatoes were served on grits with a savory sauce and were great. The Berries and burrata were a nice refreshing appetizer with fresh fruit and light burrata. The spicy chicken sandwich was fantastic. It wasn't spicy, but the sauce was flavorful and the portion size was great. The fries were tasty and crispy but very salty. The chocolate pillow is probably the most photographed pastry from Gallery. While it looks beautiful, it tasted like a light chocolate mousse and wasn't particularly special at the $10 price point. The service was slow but it was understandable because it was a busy afternoon. Overall another great brunch option in Indy and will be back.